Amityville Music Hall

Reviews

• Remi C.

  star star star star star_border 22 October 2026

  This is an A-OK dive bar, that got bumped up a start because their well whiskey was actually startingly good. Now, when you're paying $4 (or $6, cheap at any rate) for a PBR and a shot of whiskey, you aren't gonna complain too much. BUT, honestly, the PBR is....PBR, but the whisky was a good call.
  
  Saw a friend in his band perform there. Thought the cover was a bit of a killer, but the acoustics were good and they even had free rice/beans/pork in the back. SO, I'll be coming back!

• Joe H.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 15 October 2026

  This place would thrive with just a little bit of advertising/ Social media to promote. Small venue but big sound. Drinks are reasonable but cover charge was not.

• Eric S.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 12 October 2026

  So I drove 4 and a half hrs up from Harrisburg, PA to see Dying Fetus. I only recently started to appreciate their newest album so I was excited to see them again. The first step into the "Music Hall" and it's basically wall to wall people, I could stand at the bar and that was about it. I wanted to make my back to the merch table but that was all the way in the back in an outside patio area and it was basically just squeezing around people to try and move the whole way. They clearly oversold this show. I don't know what the max capacity is here but I've never before been to a venue that I thought the Fire Marshall should've been called because if a fire would've broke out here, people would've trampled each other to death trying to get out. Only because I wanted to see the band and drove over 4 hrs were the only reasons why I didn't make that call. The band sounded good and I got my merch but I left the venue regretting my decision to make this trip.

• R C.

  star star star star star_border 5 October 2026

  Tiny, TINY, Tiny little dive bar. Perfect for seeing shows as long as you anticipate being hot, crowded and sweaty. They really need to up there social media game. No real website, or real instagram. Facebook posts are too little to late. When you call you get a recording. This place could be an amazing place for up and coming bands. If they need a social media manager I am available. LOL

• Katelyn M.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 3 October 2026

  Some girl came up to my friend and started punching her and pulling her hair for absolutely no reason. I immediately went to grab my friend to get her out of it. Instead of security trying to break it up themselves, they instead pulled me off, and then put my friend in a chokehold. They proceeded to kick us out only and not the girls that instigated the fight. I have no idea why they handled a situation like this in such a manor. Absolutely disgusting. Do not waste your money here. If I could give no stars, I would.